Weekly Response: Week 4
Recall from Monday’s reading and class discussion that Bradley Hooker thinks that a plausible approach to Rule Consequentialism (1) should endorse some kind of rule about preventing disasters/serious harms due to noncompliance, but (2) shouldn’t be too demanding (i.e., it shouldn’t require us to donate ALL of our discretionary income to effective charities, like Peter Singer’s act consequentialism demands of us). The reason why Hooker would reject a rule that says something like “donate all your discretionary income to charity when doing so is necessary to prevent disaster/serious harm due to non-compliance” is that he thinks there is a high “maintenance cost” of sustaining people’s commitment to that kind of rule and teaching it to the young. He thinks, due to human selfishness, this kind of rule could be successfully taught to and sustained in people only at great cost.
So, his argument looks something like this:
P1) Rules that have a high maintenance cost aren’t part of the optimific set.
P2) A super demanding rule about aiding those in need (e.g., donate all your discretionary income to charity when doing so is necessary to prevent disaster/serious harm due to non-compliance) has a high maintenance cost.
C) A super demanding rule about aiding those in need isn’t part of the optimific set.
In your discussion post, I would like you to do a few things (and you must answer all questions to receive any credit):
(1) Do you personally agree with P2 of Hooker’s argument? Why or why not? How might someone object to P2?
Attached Files (PDF/DOCX): Week 4 notes PHIL.pdf
Note: Content extraction from these files is restricted, please review them manually.
Calculate the price of your order
Select your paper details and see how much our professional writing services will cost.
- Freebies
- Format
- Formatting (MLA, APA, Chicago, custom, etc.)
- Title page & bibliography
- 24/7 customer support
- Amendments to your paper when they are needed
- Chat with your writer
- 275 word/double-spaced page
- 12 point Arial/Times New Roman
- Double, single, and custom spacing
-
We care about originality
Our custom human-written papers from top essay writers are always free from plagiarism.
-
We protect your privacy
Your data and payment info stay secured every time you get our help from an essay writer.
-
You control your money
Your money is safe with us. If your plans change, you can get it sent back to your card.
How it works
-
1
You give us the detailsComplete a brief order form to tell us what kind of paper you need.
-
2
We find you a top writerOne of the best experts in your discipline starts working on your essay.
-
3
You get the paper doneEnjoy writing that meets your demands and high academic standards!
Get your own paper from top experts
Order nowPerks of our essay writing service
We offer more than just hand-crafted papers customized for you. Here are more of our greatest perks.
Frequently asked questions
Get instant answers to the questions that students ask most often.
See full FAQHow do you find the best essay writer for me?
Our professional writing service focuses on giving you the right specialist so the one assigned will have the knowledge about the right topic. However, if you’ve used our essay service before, you can ask us to assign you the expert writer who used to complete papers for you in the past. We can easily do so if the specialist in question is available at the moment.
If you’re ordering from our essay writing service for the first time, we will assign you a suitable expert ourselves and ensure that your academic essay writer is a pro. Moreover, let us know how complex your assignment is so that we can find the best match for your order.
We’ve hired the best writers in 80+ academic subjects to complete any paper you need. As soon as we hear, “Write my essays,” our support team assigns you the writer who understands your needs and subject.
In case you need to make sure we’ve picked a great specialist to deal with your paper, you can chat with the expert writers directly. We do our best to make sure you’re happy with the writer we’ve selected for you.
How can you prove that your paper writing service is not a scam?
We have been selling original essays for more than 15 years. To prove that we are a trustworthy custom essay writing company, we provide quick delivery and a money-back guarantee. If we can’t complete your paper for any reason, we’ll send your money back to the credit card. We want to deliver the finest services, so you can decide if the paper is good enough; from our side, we’ll edit it according to your primary requirements to make the writing perfect. Our online paper writing service is about both giving you the materials you need when you need them and ensuring that your private data is safe. Check out our guarantees to see how we control the quality of your assignment and protect you as a customer.